Valuing variations under FIDIC 1999 and 2017: a variation assessment example
Variations are where most of a QS's judgement goes. The FIDIC Red Book separates the questions: may the works be varied, how is a variation instructed, and how is it valued.
The clauses
| Subject | 1999 | 2017 |
|---|---|---|
| Engineer's instructions | 3.3 | 3.5 |
| Right to vary | 13.1 | 13.1 |
| Variation procedure | 13.3 | 13.3.1 (by instruction), 13.3.2 (by request for proposal) |
| Measurement and evaluation | Clause 12 (12.3) | Clause 12 (12.3), applied through 13.3.1 |
Particular Conditions often amend these provisions, and subcontracts set their own procedure. Read both before you start.
Choosing the rate
The contract's evaluation provisions decide whether an existing rate, an adjusted rate or a new rate is appropriate. In practice the reasoning usually runs like this, but the contract's own tests govern:
- Contract rate: where the varied work is of similar character and carried out under similar conditions to an item in the BOQ.
- Adjusted (pro-rata) rate: where an existing rate is a fair basis but needs adjusting for a difference, for example a thicker wall valued from a thinner wall's rate.
- New rate: where no rate is appropriate, built from reasonable cost plus overheads and profit, using any percentage stated in the contract.
What a good variation assessment shows
The instruction reference, the measured quantity (with a dimension sheet), the rate and why it was chosen, any omission netted off, and time consequences kept separate from cost.
Standard form or your contract? References here are to the published FIDIC Red Book (1999 and 2017). Particular Conditions, the subcontract and the governing law often change them: always read your own contract first.
Value variations on three QS Mentor projects, from a moved meeting room to a metro duct-bank claim. Start free.